Version 1 - Primary Nav Search

Mark Marengo:

Today, I am pleased to be joined by General Chris Cavoli, who retired after nearly four decades of service in the United States Army. Most recently as the 20th Supreme Allied Commander of Europe and Commander of the U.S. European Command. Since retiring from military service, General Cavoli has joined Valor Equity Partners, giving him a unique vantage point at the intersection of national national security, technology innovation, and private capital. And he also sits on the External Advisory Council for J.P. Morgan's Security and Resiliency Initiative. Welcome, General Cavoli. Thanks for being with us.

Chris Cavoli:

Thanks, Mark. Great to be here.

Mark Marengo:

So let's start with your experience as Allied Commander, where you oversaw the development of NATO's collective defense plans at a point in time when member nations were increasing their budgets, developing capabilities, and expanding the capacity for defense production. What is your view on how policy, budget, and plans have come together to build capabilities to deter our adversaries?

Chris Cavoli:

Yeah. So, Mark, it's a massive success story. But it's, like many success stories, one born of necessity. And it's incomplete. After the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022, the heads of state and government of NATO directed my predecessor, Tod Wolters, immediately to generate such a plan. I took command five days later. And so the story of my tenure was developing these plans. The plans were put together in very short order, about a year, got them approved at the summit in Vilnius in 2023. And that has made all the difference. We know what we need to build. We know what we got to do, but now we've run into two challenges. Number one, we got to actually come through, right? We have to do the hard political work to make sure our populations understand why we're going to be spending more and what we're going to be spending on. Second, there's a problem with the defense production capacity on both sides of the Atlantic. We're all working hard on it, but we've got money to spend and we need more stuff to spend it on.

Mark Marengo:

One of the key drivers for these collective defense plans was Russia's invasion of Ukraine.

Chris Cavoli:

Absolutely.

Mark Marengo:

I mean, during the conflict, we've seen technology actively shape the battlefield and the future of warfare. So, as we sit here today, where is the gap widest between what modern warfare now demands and what the traditional industrial base is actually set up and equipped to deliver?

Chris Cavoli:

This is a super important question. There's sort of a missing part to Western arsenals, and that part is affordable, capable, attributable mass. So good enough to do the job, but easy to manufacture and therefore low-cost so that we can have a deeper magazine of weapon systems. Why is this important? It's important because of the old problem. If a $40,000 drone has to be shot down with a $4 million missile, the cost exchange ratio is working against us. And nobody can afford to do that for a long time. So what we're really seeing in Ukraine is the rapid build-out of a capability to build adequate, inexpensive munitions at massive scale.

Mark Marengo:

And what are some of the other lessons learned that we've taken back from that conflict and are now deploying here in the U.S.?

Chris Cavoli:

First of all, everything is contested all the time. There aren't safe spaces. Your network's not safe. Your air base isn't safe. Your headquarters, there are no safe spaces. Second, there are no safe spaces because the battlefield has become transparent. The adversary can see almost everything and we can see almost everything. That greatly complicates maneuver. Third, the things that matter most are sometimes things you can't see. This electromagnetic warfare is going to be a very, very important part of how war is waged in the next 10 to 15 years.

Mark Marengo:

So how should investors think about allocating capital as both the U.S. and our allies try to balance rearmament, as you pointed out, in service with forced modernization?

Chris Cavoli:

A very important point here is that the defense tech world right now has sort of reversed the traditional way we did business. Traditionally, a government, a military would say, "I want the following things. I want a weapon that can do X, Y, and Z." And we would put that out to industry. Industry would come back and tell us how they would make exactly what we were asking for. The defense tech world is doing it quite the reverse, right? They're looking and they're trying to see a problem. And when they see a problem out there that the military has, they come up with novel solutions to it and then offer them. The thing to watch for is, what are the principal warfighting problems our militaries face now or will face in the future, and who is coming up with novel, disruptive ways to solve those problems in the future, rather than the older method of just watching what requirements are issued by the military and hoping to get a piece of that.

Mark Marengo:

How do you invest ahead of recognizing the budgeting process, the limitations of the budgeting process, and how that works? How do you ultimately gain conviction around a capability that you think the DOW will need at some point?

Chris Cavoli:

It starts with an understanding of how warfare is evolving. It starts with an understanding of what our militaries possess now and what capabilities they have. Second part of it is to have a good understanding of what's out there. What is industry working on? What is going to become available and what would work? Then you put those two things together and you start to see the possibilities. Critically after that, there has to be a government that wants to buy them.

Mark Marengo:

Valor works with a lot of companies and management teams to help them scale. And you bring a lot of resources to bear to do so. How do you work with management teams specifically to help them from seed capital all the way through to growth capital and really help them scale their business to achieve success?

Chris Cavoli:

Yeah, so Valor is very proud of our focus on operational assistance for our portfolio companies. We really believe that our mission is to serve the companies and the entrepreneurs who found those companies that are going to make the world a better place, in the case we're talking about today, through securing our national security. So how do we do it? We try to get to know companies very well. We have something called a scale group. It is a group of operators, lean manufacturing specialists, engineers, revenue generation specialists, operational finance. About a third of the employees of Valor are in that group rather than on an investment team or something. Once we develop some conviction in a company and they're ready to scale, we will actually deploy scale group resources, people into that company, and they will live in the company helping to solve problems. You know, most entrepreneurs scale one company in their lives, right? A couple, maybe. We have people in the scale group who've done nothing but scale companies year after year after year. So we like to think that really helps the company. As we continue to work inside the company, it gives us the opportunity to get to know them better and better and then to concentrate a more significant position in that company and capitalize the things that they require to grow even bigger.

Mark Marengo:

What else can governments be doing to help accelerate the deployment of capital to ultimately build these capabilities, to deploy these capabilities at pace and at scale, more so than what we're doing today?

Chris Cavoli:

The first thing is to talk to industry about the problems that our militaries foresee, right? To lay problems out there rather than requirements all the time. Sometimes you have to lay requirements, but engaging in a broader discussion with industry about the problems that need to be solved... That's the first step. The second thing that needs to be done is capital needs to be provided. So you have to connect or provide for the connection of those companies to people who can capitalize the company so that they can grow. A couple of ways to do that. The Office of Strategic Capital, which has grown significantly in the last couple of years, is able to provide credit at very, very attractive rates for companies that need to grow. And that is very helpful.

Mark Marengo:

And one of the things that we've seen, certainly, is when private capital, firms like Valor, partner with financial institutions like J.P. Morgan and partner with the government through a public-to-private partnership and all kind of lock arms. And everybody do a little bit more than what they would or take a little bit more risk than what they would otherwise normally do. It's amazing the problems that you can solve.

Chris Cavoli:

Absolutely. And problem-solving is what we're here for, right? I mean, when I retired from the Army, I saw problems that I mean, when I retired from the Army, I saw problems that needed to be solved, and I'm just grateful to have a chance to keep trying to solve them.

Mark Marengo:

General Cavoli, thank you for being here.

Chris Cavoli:

Thanks, Mark.

Mark Marengo:

And thank you for your service and everything you've done for our country.

END

The nature of warfare continues to evolve. Technology is actively shaping the battlefield while exposing a gap between what modern warfare demands and what the traditional industrial base is set up to deliver. Closing that gap is now a priority for militaries, industry and investors on both sides of the Atlantic.

General Chris Cavoli has a unique view of that challenge. He retired after nearly four decades in the U.S. Army, most recently as the 20th Supreme Allied Commander Europe and Commander of U.S. European Command. Today he works at the intersection of national security, technology innovation and private capital, at Valor Equity Partners and as a member of SRI's External Advisory Council. In conversation with Mark Marengo, head of diversified industries investment banking at J.P. Morgan, he explained what it will take to build capability at pace and scale.

About the Security and Resiliency Initiative

J.P. Morgan’s Security and Resiliency Initiative is a $1.5 trillion, 10-year plan to facilitate, finance and invest in industries critical to national economic security and resiliency. It includes direct equity investments for an initial amount of $10 billion. Defense and Aerospace is one of five focus areas and covers defense technology, autonomous systems, next-gen connectivity and secure communications. 

Related insights