Despite their recent growth, exchange-traded funds still struggle to crack the
stranglehold mutual funds have on the retirement market. Best estimates currently
place ETFs at less than 5% of all assets in 401(k) plans.
But that may be changing. Several new ETF-friendly plan providers and record-keepers
have emerged in recent years, and ETF titan iShares recently
announced a new program to simplify the use of these instruments for retirement
plans.
“ETFs can solve a huge problem in 401(k) plans by lowering fees,”
says Darwin Abrahamson, CEO of Invest n Retire LLC, an ETF-friendly 401(k) recordkeeping
service in Portland, Oregon.
The technical challenges that once prevented ETFs from being used in 401(k)
plans have largely been resolved, says Abrahamson.
Historically, most 401(k) recordkeeping and accounting systems were designed
to accommodate mutual funds, which trade once daily at the end of the day, and
can always be bought and sold in fractional shares.
ETFs, however, may only be purchased as whole shares, like a stock. And since
most 401(k) investors automatically fund their accounts through payroll deduction,
their contributions rarely equal the exact cost of a certain number of ETF shares.
Further, placing 12 or 26 or 52 small-lot trades per year into a variety of
ETF positions through a traditional brokerage mechanism would quickly eat into
returns through commissions and bid/ask spreads.
“There just weren't many recordkeeping systems that could accommodate
individual ETFs,” says Abrahamson.
One solution is trade aggregation systems, which is what Abrahamson’s
group has developed. Under Invest n Retire’s program, smaller trades are
aggregated under a larger group plan, keeping transaction costs low while circumventing
the fractional share issue. “On the plan level, it’s all whole shares,”
says Abrahamson. “But the participants themselves see fractional shares.”
For now, WisdomTree, which launched its own all-ETF platform two years ago,
is the only ETF provider jumping into 401(k)s with both feet, targeting a niche
of advisers who work with small and midsize companies. It’s a good match:
advisers are increasingly comfortable with ETFs, and the smaller plans are unlikely
targets for direct 401(k) plan sales from the major investment management firms.
iShares, the world’s largest ETF provider, has dipped
a marketing toe in the water: it launched its “iShares in 401(k) Program”
in April, which connects financial advisers with iShares-friendly third-party
plan providers and administrators.
But despite these entrants, neither Vanguard nor Fidelity Investments—the
two largest 401(k) plan providers—have announced any intention to offer
ETFs in their plans, even though Vanguard is also the world’s third-largest
ETF provider.
Ultimately the main barrier for the larger players may not be technological,
but financial. Mutual funds are the vehicle of choice in many 401(k) plans,
in part because the higher fee structure allows plans to offset recordkeeping
costs through revenue sharing under the funds’ expense ratio umbrella.
In ETF-centric 401(k)s, recordkeeping expenses are more transparent, and must
be either picked up by the plan sponsor or charged to plan participants as a
separate fee.
That level of transparency may be better for investors, but established plan
providers have so far been reluctant to change. As more and more ETF recordkeeping
systems gain traction, however, they may be forced to adapt.
Copyright © 2012 JPMorgan Chase & Co. All rights reserved.